So at this moment, my dad still has the title in his name and he’s paying the insurance. Next week, we’re switching the title to my name and I’ve just purchased an insurance policy.
I will own. a. car. I don’t really think I should be trusted to own anything, so I’m thinking that there’s gotta be a trick somewhere.
And I feel really guilty that Dad’s giving me a whole car — but then I remember how they didn’t have to pay a cent of my college education and I know that would have cost far more than my car, so…maybe I don’t feel quite so bad. Still spoiled, but deservingly so?
Anyway, the real point: WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON WITH CAR INSURANCE? I don’t get it.
I decided to see if Geico and Progressive are really as awesome as their ads claim — if nothing else, I like the idea of getting a quote without having to talk to a real person, especially a real person who’s trying to get hundreds of dollars from me.
First I got a quote from Geico. It was a lot of money, but fair.
Then I got a letter from Liberty Mutual (because the fucking Alumni Association sold my contact info to fucking every company in the world) that said they’re offering a discount to recent graduates. So I called them up to get a quote. HOLY WHOA. They were asking 50% more. Why is there that big of a difference?
(I ended up buying a renters insurance policy from them instead. Hopefully they didn’t rip me off on that one — $13/month sounded like a deal to me.)
Then I went back online and got a quote from Progressive. Even cheaper than Geico — like 20% cheaper. I’m sold.
I understand that insurance is tricky because it’s about complicated risks and a fair amount of randomness, so of course not every company is going to offer me the same exact price. But shouldn’t it all be reduced down to a system that’s at least vaguely consistent? Shouldn’t someone have come up with a universal formula by now?
If Liberty Mutual wants to charge me five or six hundred dollars more than Progressive, how the hell do they stay in business? Are they ripping everyone off, or just new college graduates with a single accident on their records?
I’m sure someone could provide me with a detailed, rational explanation for why insurance companies are so dumb. Or maybe the answer is that Progressive is going to jack up my rates the first chance they get. But, damn, these companies are so dumb.
Posted: 8:28 am ·
Category: Cars, Rants ·
Comments: 2